×

Civilian Policing In New York Does Not Make Sense

A society that treats public safety as a political experiment eventually learns the consequences the hard way. From rising tensions over policing and crime to debates about protests, civic order, government priorities, media narratives, and the growing influence of progressive political movements, the battle isn't just about policy. It's about whether leadership values results or symbolism. Supporters call it reform. Critics call it dismantling the very systems that keep cities functioning wh...

Show Notes

A society that treats public safety as a political experiment eventually learns the consequences the hard way. From rising tensions over policing and crime to debates about protests, civic order, government priorities, media narratives, and the growing influence of progressive political movements, the battle isn't just about policy. It's about whether leadership values results or symbolism. Supporters call it reform. Critics call it dismantling the very systems that keep cities functioning when violence, unrest, and emergencies erupt. Across North America, concerns are growing that ideological agendas are being prioritised over practical solutions, leaving businesses, families, commuters, and communities wondering who's really looking out for their safety. When public trust erodes and accountability disappears, the biggest risk isn't disagreement. It's discovering too late that good intentions don't stop chaos.

#Politics #BreakingNews #CurrentEvents #PublicSafety #Crime #LawAndOrder #Leadership #Democracy #News #PoliticalCommentary #Government #Freedom #TrendingNow #America #Security

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

#TheRantNetwork #StuartBrisgel #DavidSolomon #RantNetwork #RantNetworkPodcast #Politics #PoliticalCommentary #Conservative #AntiWoke #NewsCommentary #PodcastsOfInstagram #PoliticalPodcast

The Rant Revolution: Unleashing Passionate Perspectives on The Rant Network

Who We Are And Why We Are Doing This? Stuart Brisgel, from the United States, and David Solomon, from Canada, have debated so many different topics. M...

Show Transcript

Travel Chaos After FAA Outage

SPEAKER_00 0:04

Monday morning. The day after the big FAA boom. Friday, if you are flying and you're still trying to get home, good luck if you're traveling today. Wow. Stuart, I don't know about you. I booked a trip over the weekend. I got my way next week for part of the week, and like one of the options was to fly through the U.S. And I went, ah no, not

NYC Plans Civilian Protest Response

SPEAKER_00 0:26

for a while. Anyways, on that note, speaking of changes, tell me what's wrong with this picture. Police are trained to keep the peace. And sometimes keeping the peace doesn't mean being doing it in a peaceful way, because the people doing it are attacking violent. And we've seen this in quite a few protests, whether it was during the George Floyd period or most recently, of course, these pro-terrorist groups who love to run around and they shattered Columbia University and they burn things, and there are effigies and violence and physical assault. And we've seen many of these okay, you know, these cases. But apparently, one mayor thinks it's wrong. That the the the we should disband the tactical unit, Stuart. Exchange for civilians, because civilians know how to do this, Stuart. I think this is just the sign, the first step, and something very scary.

SPEAKER_01 1:31

All right, let's start off with New York City. Mayor Mandami just fired its insurance policy. Yep. So if you're a creditor in the state of New York and municipal bond of any kind, Mandami just said your valuation points are going to drop. Zora Mandani is gutting the New York Police Department Elites Tactical Unit One that handles riots, terror threats, mass unrest, and is swapping it for a civilian-led protest response, kind of like the Germans did in 1933. Something called the SS. I want you to sit with that for a second, because if you try and ask ChatGPT or any online chat, it's gonna fight you on me even mentioning this, which is what I like most of all about today's segment. Let me tell you this. I want you to sit with that. Because before I even get start yelling, civilians leading response to the next time there's a Times Square bomb scare. How about the next subway stampede that possibly has anthrax or some other unknown biologic? Or how about you know, a spill that had a stampede or a riot like in Washington Square at 2 a.m. Let's go get those volunteers out with their what? Baseball bats? What crowbars? What their SS on their shoulders? This isn't a press release about reimagining public safety. This is an actual operational decision. It's happening right now in the largest city in America with 8 million

What Defunding Police Changed Elsewhere

SPEAKER_01 3:20

people safety sitting on the other side and all the tourists that are along for the ride. And I've seen this in the movies. We we all have. Minneapolis didn't theorize about defunding police.

They actually did it after 2020. And the department bled through in the towel officers for years while violent crimes climbed and stayed up. Portland disbanded its riot unit in 2021 after officers quit en masse because DA wouldn't back them up in court. So when the next crowd turned violent, there was nobody left with training to respond.

Chicago put its tactical and gang units under a microscope in the name of reform and carjackings and shootings spike alongside the paperwork. This is the same ideology, the same sequence, same promise, community-led, civilian-based, trust building, same ending every time. Don't have to be a rocket scientist to understand if you do the same thing over and over again and expect a different result, you're insane. Bandami, you're insane.

Let me be clear, right? Every time, fewer trained officers, slower response equals more dead bodies on the pavement, while City Hall and City Workers have a new org chart to show you. Here's who plays for the vibe. The shift working, taking 4 a.m.

train to midnight, the small business owner who boarded up his storefront in 2020 and never got the plywood bill reimbursed, the B cop who now has to run into a crowd that used to have trained tactical teams backing him up and doesn't have that. Madami himself didn't put that in the equation. He put every ordinary New Yorker instead, or so you might think. New York spent decades building the most capable urban police force on the planet post-9-11, post-Bloomberg era, Comstat, the whole machine.

One mayor, a handful of months, and a job. He's dismantling the part that's built for everyday things go wrong. On a theory that everything failed in three American cities, you can name. You don't find out civilian-led doesn't work in a committee meeting.

You find out on the worst night of the year when people who used to show up don't. Let me tell you, ladies and gentlemen, I promise you this is exactly what the left insane asylum wants you to do. Didn't you see Batman? That is sale

Why Training Matters In Real Crises

SPEAKER_01 6:06

asylums filled with all those Democrats, and you just let them all go.

SPEAKER_00 6:10

David. Oh wow, that was quick today. Stuart, let me tell you something. You know what bugs me?

Let's tell you what bugs me. Mamdani is slipping slowly but surely stripping away what New Yorkers need, and that is protection. Do you remember? I don't know, Stuart, if you were uh you're old enough to remember the 1970s, what New York looked like.

Homeless people, crime, buildings were burning. It was a disaster. New York was a literal disaster. The epicenter of America's finance, the Broadway district, whatever, was a scary place to be.

People didn't want to walk at night. And that was when police just didn't, you know, nobody cared, didn't do the job. And here we are, years later, after much cleaning and thanks to many different mayors, New York became a much, much safer city because New York's finest, and I say it's finest, did what it had to. Stuart, let me remind people that on September 11, 2001, how many police officers, how many police officers put their lives on the line, lost their lives to save people after one of the great after the greatest disaster that hit American soil.

Will you tell me that uh Mamdani's civilian crew is gonna go and do something like that? Stuart, that's what police do. Police are trained and are like that's their mindset is to help civilians in the most difficult times. Putting in civilians who are untrained is suicide.

It's just gonna lead to more chaos and more cat catastrophes. And I guess that's what Mamdani wants from New York. He'd rather pontificate about Israel, he'd rather tell you how you'd rather arrest Benjamin Netanyahu. He'd rather kind of tell you we need to divest from Israel rather than protect the citizens of New York City that he swore to protect on his Quran.

Don't get me started on that. That's an oxymoron. Okay, so here's the thing. Back in 2020, when it was cool to go ahead and say we're defunding the police, and 21 cities announced that they were defunding the police, 14 Stuart reversed course almost immediately because they realized this was a disaster.

It was a great, it's great for politics. It's wonderful showmanship. And that's what Mamdani is. He's a P.

T. Barnum. He is a clown. He's a circus leader.

He's trying to, he's convinced a whole bunch of young people he's got it right. And unfortunately, with socialism being hot and popular with a bunch of young, innocent, dumb, inexperienced, you know, 20-year-olds, this is great. But what Mamdani is going to do is he's gonna take he's gonna basically take Jessica Tish, who's the chief of police of the New York, and basket basically tell her he ain't running the show anymore. I'm running the show.

I will take care of the people. Now, it's it's it's interesting to see that this is how this will play out. And others say, Stuart, because when when Bam Dani starts with his dumb shit, others think it's a great idea. So be prepared for higher crime rates, more violence.

You know, the problem, Stuart, is that you know, when a when a violent group decides it needs to protest and it burns down or defaces property. I mean, let's let's take a situation called Times Square, right? How many tourists go through Times Square every year? Now, according to what Mam Dani's gonna do, what would happen if his there's a protest there and they simply smash every store in Times Square?

What is this civilian group gonna do?

SPEAKER_01 9:52

Well, hang on a second, hang on a second. That's a theory that just happened in France and caused a billion dollars plus of damage. This is what I was asking.

SPEAKER_00 10:02

Right? The police had to use pretty tough measures in France, a socialist government, because of what was at stake here. Oh, and by the way, Louis Vuitton and other ones, they they were they had enough money to put out their own physical security, but that's what's gonna happen, Stuart. You're gonna turn New York into a you know, the if I were now today, I would open up a private security company and offer my services to New Yorkers, because that's what it's gonna need.

Every business, every person is gonna need extra security. Because Mamdani doesn't really care about the safety of his people, he cares about himself, and he cares only about his political stance as Stewart. And that I think is what's disgusting about Mam Dani. And again, folks, those of you in New York who are gonna rip me apart or rip Stuart apart, you voted him in.

Remember, you're the one who voted him in. He promised you free bus rides, he promised you, you know, government subsidized supermarkets, he gave you all these wacky doodle ideas that you all thought were brilliant, original. History has proven that it's not original and it's a complete chaos. That's what Mamdani is chasing.

Chaos so that he can blame. He loves to blame. He'll blame Jews, he'll blame Republicans, he'll find a way to blame you too. Don't worry, it's coming.

Stuart, I think that New York City is done for. I think in year one of the Mamdani reign, we've seen what this guy stands for and believes in. And sadly to say, Stuart, three more years of Mamdani and many other socialists. I don't think, you know, could you imagine this is brought to the Senate?

Could you imagine now the Senate is gonna pass legislation that we will no longer have police, you know, helping ourselves? We're gonna have a civilian civilians are gonna police themselves. Uh sorry, Stuart. I I I just can't go for that.

SPEAKER_01 12:01

I don't blame you. And you know what?

Canada Argument Protest Or Riot

SPEAKER_01 12:04

But again, let's talk about Canada, the riots in the streets that are taking place in Toronto, in Montreal. What are you saying?

SPEAKER_00 12:12

Stuart, what what riot can you quote for me from Montreal, please? Can you give me a riot that happened just recently, please? Can you please do so? Because what you're talking to me about is non-existent. And and and Canada, yes, Toronto has Toronto, just to show you, Toronto and Montreal have fully subsidized uh police forces, they're just not doing their job.

SPEAKER_01 12:31

So so so so the riot, okay, November 13th, the student class with riot police didn't happen on November 13th.

SPEAKER_00 12:40

Stuart, steward, steward.

SPEAKER_01 12:41

I love let's let's let's let me quote media from March coalition, you know, resistance pour les unites du temps, I live in Montreal.

SPEAKER_00 12:50

May I tell you what happened?

SPEAKER_01 12:52

Vigor, St. Alexander Street, near the Palais de Capay. Stuart demonstrates through rocks, fireworks. Dude, you live in the West Island.

SPEAKER_00 13:00

Stuart okay, Stewart, Stewart. When you quote media that loves hysteria, we had it, we had a protest. Absolutely. Hold on, we had a protest, and I'm not here to defend them. Believe in me, I'm not here to defend them. But what's happening? What's it in a protest and riot?

SPEAKER_01 13:17

Let's define protest, let's define protest and riot. That's what I'm trying to say to you. Protest where rocks are thrown, or is that a right?

SPEAKER_00 13:24

Stuart, Stuart, If you're gonna tell are you the I'm gonna ask you a question. When you get a handful of students, which is apparently what it was, throwing rocks at police and this and that, and if they learn from the French, it's okay. They learned from how they do it in France and in Europe, that's okay. Were there were there actors who were there? Absolutely. Would I call this a riot? No. And I'll tell you why. Yes, they throw things in, this happens here, whatever. But when I see stop, I call what happened in France a riot. I see when I when I see people like what George Floyd, that to me is a riot. When the Canadians won the Stanley Cup in '93, and they they and you and I were both in the state at the time. Okay, that's a riot.

SPEAKER_01 14:06

David, David, okay. The the demonstration was a it's called coalition that has this. You don't have to educate me in my own city. David, David, there were thousands of people at its peak, and it was roughly a hundred thousand people across Quebec wide students striking. So that's not a riot, that's a protest. You're going, you're don't call it.

SPEAKER_00 14:28

Riots begin when rocks are you know one thing, Stuart, one thing you're you're you're you're you're and uh and this is we've completely derailed it. I okay, let's call it a riot because you just like to you just like to piss on Canada. So here's the thing about riots, okay? Here's the difference, Stuart. There were police there and they stopped them. There were police there and they stopped it from escalating to a point where it would have gone even worse had there been civilians doing this. Untrained civilians, the Palais de Congress, our car.

SPEAKER_01 15:01

We're getting there, but but let's keep going. Then I let's talk about Ontario, where Guelph homecoming turned into chaos, where 13,000 people ended up running down Chancellor Way with an unsanctioned party.

SPEAKER_00 15:14

So that's a riot.

SPEAKER_01 15:16

How about Bluer Street bike lanes removed protests?

SPEAKER_00 15:19

Yes, Stuart, Stuart, Stuart, let me let me think of this like every Western Stuart, every Western city is being is getting protests. These are many of them are paid actors.

SPEAKER_01 15:33

Thank you. Thank you. So now you're starting to agree with me. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_00 15:37

I disagree with you because what I love, I what I love from you, Stuart, is when we talk about the US, you need to bring Canada in. Right now, no one in Canada has defunded the police. We're talking about Mamdani trying to defund the police in the United States. I'm sorry, David.

SPEAKER_01 15:53

The police is already defunded in Canada because there are no funds in Canada.

SPEAKER_00 15:57

It is Oh my God, here we go again. Stuart with his Canadian knowledge. It's incredible. Look, ladies and gentlemen, Stewart once again shows me that if it happens in Can in the US, we've got to bring in Canada into a conversation because two wrongs make a right.

Media Incentives And Political Blame Game

SPEAKER_00 16:13

Stuart, for me, Mamdani is a clown. He's a fucking clown and he should be thrown out of office. He's a racist piece of garbage and he's trying to hurt New Yorkers. That's the focus. Montreal has its own problems. Toronto has its own problems. Detroit, Chicago, Miami, Los Angeles have their own problems. Mamdani is teaching American mayors how to ruin their city even further.

SPEAKER_01 16:40

I was barely bringing up little Marky Carney in Canada just because it's as fucked up there as ever.

SPEAKER_00 16:49

That's like bringing up Trump and saying Trump is responsible for New York. Trump's not responsible for New York. He Trump has no jurisdiction in New York. Trump is the president of the United States. Mamdani's the mayor. He gets to talk about budgets in New York and where the money's going to go and how people are going to be safe. Trump is a citizen of New York. That's all it is. Mark Kearney is the Prime Minister of Canada. Who cares? It's irrelevant. What we're seeing here is what we're seeing here is that a lefty, these lefty, so-called progressive mayors, governors, senators, congresspeople, members of parliament, Stuart, don't care about public safety. Let's just call it a spade. All right. They don't. They just don't. Mamdani wants to see violence. And the more violence, the more he can blame. Because that's what media gives him, gives him a chance. Stuart, the media gives him a pass every time these things happen. If something goes wrong, they'll blame Jessica Tisch, the chief of police who happened to be Jewish. So we must blame the Jews. It's a wonderful formula, Stuart. Look at New York.

SPEAKER_01 17:55

Come on. You're right. Chicago, New York, Oregon, Portland. Sorry. Portland? Seattle?

SPEAKER_00 18:02

I mean, Seattle is trying to tell the whole world that defunding the police works. Meanwhile, you don't hear about all the damage and the riots and whatever. Where what? Why not? Why not? Let's leave it at that, Stuart. Okay, because you seem to you seem to be speechless.

SPEAKER_01 18:20

It's already a quarter hour. We're out of here. David. My people.

Comments & Upvotes

Chapters
  1. 0:00 Travel Chaos After FAA Outage
  2. 0:26 NYC Plans Civilian Protest Response
  3. 3:20 What Defunding Police Changed Elsewhere
  4. 6:06 Why Training Matters In Real Crises
  5. 12:04 Canada Argument Protest Or Riot
  6. 16:13 Media Incentives And Political Blame Game
Transcript

Travel Chaos After FAA Outage SPEAKER_00 0:04 Monday morning. The day after the big FAA boom. Friday, if you are flying and you're still trying to get home, good luck if you're traveling today. Wow.

Stuart, I don't know about you. I booked a trip over the weekend. I got my way next week for part of the week, and like one of the options was to fly through the U.S. And I went, ah no, not NYC Plans Civilian Protest Response SPEAKER_00 0:26 for a while.

Anyways, on that note, speaking of changes, tell me what's wrong with this picture. Police are trained to keep the peace. And sometimes keeping the peace doesn't mean being doing it in a peaceful way, because the people doing it are attacking violent. And we've seen this in quite a few protests, whether it was during the George Floyd period or most recently, of course, these pro-terrorist groups who love to run around and they shattered Columbia University and they burn things, and there are effigies and violence and physical assault.

And we've seen many of these okay, you know, these cases. But apparently, one mayor thinks it's wrong. That the the the we should disband the tactical unit, Stuart. Exchange for civilians, because civilians know how to do this, Stuart.

I think this is just the sign, the first step, and something very scary. SPEAKER_01 1:31 All right, let's start off with New York City. Mayor Mandami just fired its insurance policy. Yep.

So if you're a creditor in the state of New York and municipal bond of any kind, Mandami just said your valuation points are going to drop. Zora Mandani is gutting the New York Police Department Elites Tactical Unit One that handles riots, terror threats, mass unrest, and is swapping it for a civilian-led protest response, kind of like the Germans did in 1933. Something called the SS. I want you to sit with that for a second, because if you try and ask ChatGPT or any online chat, it's gonna fight you on me even mentioning this, which is what I like most of all about today's segment.

Let me tell you this. I want you to sit with that. Because before I even get start yelling, civilians leading response to the next time there's a Times Square bomb scare. How about the next subway stampede that possibly has anthrax or some other unknown biologic?

Or how about you know, a spill that had a stampede or a riot like in Washington Square at 2 a.m. Let's go get those volunteers out with their what? Baseball bats? What crowbars?

What their SS on their shoulders? This isn't a press release about reimagining public safety. This is an actual operational decision. It's happening right now in the largest city in America with 8 million What Defunding Police Changed Elsewhere SPEAKER_01 3:20 people safety sitting on the other side and all the tourists that are along for the ride.

And I've seen this in the movies. We we all have. Minneapolis didn't theorize about defunding police. They actually did it after 2020.

And the department bled through in the towel officers for years while violent crimes climbed and stayed up. Portland disbanded its riot unit in 2021 after officers quit en masse because DA wouldn't back them up in court. So when the next crowd turned violent, there was nobody left with training to respond. Chicago put its tactical and gang units under a microscope in the name of reform and carjackings and shootings spike alongside the paperwork.

This is the same ideology, the same sequence, same promise, community-led, civilian-based, trust building, same ending every time. Don't have to be a rocket scientist to understand if you do the same thing over and over again and expect a different result, you're insane. Bandami, you're insane. Let me be clear, right?

Every time, fewer trained officers, slower response equals more dead bodies on the pavement, while City Hall and City Workers have a new org chart to show you. Here's who plays for the vibe. The shift working, taking 4 a.m. train to midnight, the small business owner who boarded up his storefront in 2020 and never got the plywood bill reimbursed, the B cop who now has to run into a crowd that used to have trained tactical teams backing him up and doesn't have that.

Madami himself didn't put that in the equation. He put every ordinary New Yorker instead, or so you might think. New York spent decades building the most capable urban police force on the planet post-9-11, post-Bloomberg era, Comstat, the whole machine. One mayor, a handful of months, and a job.

He's dismantling the part that's built for everyday things go wrong. On a theory that everything failed in three American cities, you can name. You don't find out civilian-led doesn't work in a committee meeting. You find out on the worst night of the year when people who used to show up don't.

Let me tell you, ladies and gentlemen, I promise you this is exactly what the left insane asylum wants you to do. Didn't you see Batman? That is sale Why Training Matters In Real Crises SPEAKER_01 6:06 asylums filled with all those Democrats, and you just let them all go. SPEAKER_00 6:10 David.

Oh wow, that was quick today. Stuart, let me tell you something. You know what bugs me? Let's tell you what bugs me.

Mamdani is slipping slowly but surely stripping away what New Yorkers need, and that is protection. Do you remember? I don't know, Stuart, if you were uh you're old enough to remember the 1970s, what New York looked like. Homeless people, crime, buildings were burning.

It was a disaster. New York was a literal disaster. The epicenter of America's finance, the Broadway district, whatever, was a scary place to be. People didn't want to walk at night.

And that was when police just didn't, you know, nobody cared, didn't do the job. And here we are, years later, after much cleaning and thanks to many different mayors, New York became a much, much safer city because New York's finest, and I say it's finest, did what it had to. Stuart, let me remind people that on September 11, 2001, how many police officers, how many police officers put their lives on the line, lost their lives to save people after one of the great after the greatest disaster that hit American soil. Will you tell me that uh Mamdani's civilian crew is gonna go and do something like that?

Stuart, that's what police do. Police are trained and are like that's their mindset is to help civilians in the most difficult times. Putting in civilians who are untrained is suicide. It's just gonna lead to more chaos and more cat catastrophes.

And I guess that's what Mamdani wants from New York. He'd rather pontificate about Israel, he'd rather tell you how you'd rather arrest Benjamin Netanyahu. He'd rather kind of tell you we need to divest from Israel rather than protect the citizens of New York City that he swore to protect on his Quran. Don't get me started on that.

That's an oxymoron. Okay, so here's the thing. Back in 2020, when it was cool to go ahead and say we're defunding the police, and 21 cities announced that they were defunding the police, 14 Stuart reversed course almost immediately because they realized this was a disaster. It was a great, it's great for politics.

It's wonderful showmanship. And that's what Mamdani is. He's a P. T.

Barnum. He is a clown. He's a circus leader. He's trying to, he's convinced a whole bunch of young people he's got it right.

And unfortunately, with socialism being hot and popular with a bunch of young, innocent, dumb, inexperienced, you know, 20-year-olds, this is great. But what Mamdani is going to do is he's gonna take he's gonna basically take Jessica Tish, who's the chief of police of the New York, and basket basically tell her he ain't running the show anymore. I'm running the show. I will take care of the people.

Now, it's it's it's interesting to see that this is how this will play out. And others say, Stuart, because when when Bam Dani starts with his dumb shit, others think it's a great idea. So be prepared for higher crime rates, more violence. You know, the problem, Stuart, is that you know, when a when a violent group decides it needs to protest and it burns down or defaces property.

I mean, let's let's take a situation called Times Square, right? How many tourists go through Times Square every year? Now, according to what Mam Dani's gonna do, what would happen if his there's a protest there and they simply smash every store in Times Square? What is this civilian group gonna do?

SPEAKER_01 9:52 Well, hang on a second, hang on a second. That's a theory that just happened in France and caused a billion dollars plus of damage. This is what I was asking. SPEAKER_00 10:02 Right?

The police had to use pretty tough measures in France, a socialist government, because of what was at stake here. Oh, and by the way, Louis Vuitton and other ones, they they were they had enough money to put out their own physical security, but that's what's gonna happen, Stuart. You're gonna turn New York into a you know, the if I were now today, I would open up a private security company and offer my services to New Yorkers, because that's what it's gonna need. Every business, every person is gonna need extra security.

Because Mamdani doesn't really care about the safety of his people, he cares about himself, and he cares only about his political stance as Stewart. And that I think is what's disgusting about Mam Dani. And again, folks, those of you in New York who are gonna rip me apart or rip Stuart apart, you voted him in. Remember, you're the one who voted him in.

He promised you free bus rides, he promised you, you know, government subsidized supermarkets, he gave you all these wacky doodle ideas that you all thought were brilliant, original. History has proven that it's not original and it's a complete chaos. That's what Mamdani is chasing. Chaos so that he can blame.

He loves to blame. He'll blame Jews, he'll blame Republicans, he'll find a way to blame you too. Don't worry, it's coming. Stuart, I think that New York City is done for.

I think in year one of the Mamdani reign, we've seen what this guy stands for and believes in. And sadly to say, Stuart, three more years of Mamdani and many other socialists. I don't think, you know, could you imagine this is brought to the Senate? Could you imagine now the Senate is gonna pass legislation that we will no longer have police, you know, helping ourselves?

We're gonna have a civilian civilians are gonna police themselves. Uh sorry, Stuart. I I I just can't go for that. SPEAKER_01 12:01 I don't blame you.

And you know what? Canada Argument Protest Or Riot SPEAKER_01 12:04 But again, let's talk about Canada, the riots in the streets that are taking place in Toronto, in Montreal. What are you saying? SPEAKER_00 12:12 Stuart, what what riot can you quote for me from Montreal, please?

Can you give me a riot that happened just recently, please? Can you please do so? Because what you're talking to me about is non-existent. And and and Canada, yes, Toronto has Toronto, just to show you, Toronto and Montreal have fully subsidized uh police forces, they're just not doing their job.

SPEAKER_01 12:31 So so so so the riot, okay, November 13th, the student class with riot police didn't happen on November 13th. SPEAKER_00 12:40 Stuart, steward, steward. SPEAKER_01 12:41 I love let's let's let's let me quote media from March coalition, you know, resistance pour les unites du temps, I live in Montreal. SPEAKER_00 12:50 May I tell you what happened?

SPEAKER_01 12:52 Vigor, St. Alexander Street, near the Palais de Capay. Stuart demonstrates through rocks, fireworks. Dude, you live in the West Island.

SPEAKER_00 13:00 Stuart okay, Stewart, Stewart. When you quote media that loves hysteria, we had it, we had a protest. Absolutely. Hold on, we had a protest, and I'm not here to defend them.

Believe in me, I'm not here to defend them. But what's happening? What's it in a protest and riot? SPEAKER_01 13:17 Let's define protest, let's define protest and riot.

That's what I'm trying to say to you. Protest where rocks are thrown, or is that a right? SPEAKER_00 13:24 Stuart, Stuart, If you're gonna tell are you the I'm gonna ask you a question. When you get a handful of students, which is apparently what it was, throwing rocks at police and this and that, and if they learn from the French, it's okay.

They learned from how they do it in France and in Europe, that's okay. Were there were there actors who were there? Absolutely. Would I call this a riot?

No. And I'll tell you why. Yes, they throw things in, this happens here, whatever. But when I see stop, I call what happened in France a riot.

I see when I when I see people like what George Floyd, that to me is a riot. When the Canadians won the Stanley Cup in '93, and they they and you and I were both in the state at the time. Okay, that's a riot. SPEAKER_01 14:06 David, David, okay.

The the demonstration was a it's called coalition that has this. You don't have to educate me in my own city. David, David, there were thousands of people at its peak, and it was roughly a hundred thousand people across Quebec wide students striking. So that's not a riot, that's a protest.

You're going, you're don't call it. SPEAKER_00 14:28 Riots begin when rocks are you know one thing, Stuart, one thing you're you're you're you're you're and uh and this is we've completely derailed it. I okay, let's call it a riot because you just like to you just like to piss on Canada. So here's the thing about riots, okay?

Here's the difference, Stuart. There were police there and they stopped them. There were police there and they stopped it from escalating to a point where it would have gone even worse had there been civilians doing this. Untrained civilians, the Palais de Congress, our car.

SPEAKER_01 15:01 We're getting there, but but let's keep going. Then I let's talk about Ontario, where Guelph homecoming turned into chaos, where 13,000 people ended up running down Chancellor Way with an unsanctioned party. SPEAKER_00 15:14 So that's a riot. SPEAKER_01 15:16 How about Bluer Street bike lanes removed protests?

SPEAKER_00 15:19 Yes, Stuart, Stuart, Stuart, let me let me think of this like every Western Stuart, every Western city is being is getting protests. These are many of them are paid actors. SPEAKER_01 15:33 Thank you. Thank you.

So now you're starting to agree with me. Thank you so much. SPEAKER_00 15:37 I disagree with you because what I love, I what I love from you, Stuart, is when we talk about the US, you need to bring Canada in. Right now, no one in Canada has defunded the police.

We're talking about Mamdani trying to defund the police in the United States. I'm sorry, David. SPEAKER_01 15:53 The police is already defunded in Canada because there are no funds in Canada. SPEAKER_00 15:57 It is Oh my God, here we go again.

Stuart with his Canadian knowledge. It's incredible. Look, ladies and gentlemen, Stewart once again shows me that if it happens in Can in the US, we've got to bring in Canada into a conversation because two wrongs make a right. Media Incentives And Political Blame Game SPEAKER_00 16:13 Stuart, for me, Mamdani is a clown.

He's a fucking clown and he should be thrown out of office. He's a racist piece of garbage and he's trying to hurt New Yorkers. That's the focus. Montreal has its own problems.

Toronto has its own problems. Detroit, Chicago, Miami, Los Angeles have their own problems. Mamdani is teaching American mayors how to ruin their city even further. SPEAKER_01 16:40 I was barely bringing up little Marky Carney in Canada just because it's as fucked up there as ever.

SPEAKER_00 16:49 That's like bringing up Trump and saying Trump is responsible for New York. Trump's not responsible for New York. He Trump has no jurisdiction in New York. Trump is the president of the United States.

Mamdani's the mayor. He gets to talk about budgets in New York and where the money's going to go and how people are going to be safe. Trump is a citizen of New York. That's all it is.

Mark Kearney is the Prime Minister of Canada. Who cares? It's irrelevant. What we're seeing here is what we're seeing here is that a lefty, these lefty, so-called progressive mayors, governors, senators, congresspeople, members of parliament, Stuart, don't care about public safety.

Let's just call it a spade. All right. They don't. They just don't.

Mamdani wants to see violence. And the more violence, the more he can blame. Because that's what media gives him, gives him a chance. Stuart, the media gives him a pass every time these things happen.

If something goes wrong, they'll blame Jessica Tisch, the chief of police who happened to be Jewish. So we must blame the Jews. It's a wonderful formula, Stuart. Look at New York.

SPEAKER_01 17:55 Come on. You're right. Chicago, New York, Oregon, Portland. Sorry.

Portland? Seattle? SPEAKER_00 18:02 I mean, Seattle is trying to tell the whole world that defunding the police works. Meanwhile, you don't hear about all the damage and the riots and whatever.

Where what? Why not? Why not? Let's leave it at that, Stuart.

Okay, because you seem to you seem to be speechless. SPEAKER_01 18:20 It's already a quarter hour. We're out of here. David.

My people.

Contact Us

×

Got a question, press inquiry or idea you'd like to share? Contact us through the form below and let us know how we can help.

Subscribe, don't miss the next episode!

×